Each NFL crew’s most overrated participant heading into 2022

The NFL has no scarcity of expertise, together with a budding group of superstars and undervalued gamers who don’t get the popularity they deserve. However there are additionally loads of gamers who’re overvalued.

After each crew’s most underrated participant, it’s time to take a look at the opposite facet of the coin with the overrated gamers within the NFL.

Overrated doesn’t essentially imply unhealthy. It simply signifies that these gamers aren’t dwelling as much as the hype, nonetheless honest or unfair it might be. For some, they’re underperforming with regard to their contract. For others, they’re not essentially assembly the excessive expectations thrust upon them.

Our NFL Wire editors recognized probably the most overrated participant for every crew heading into the 2022 season, explaining why they’re not precisely dwelling as much as hype.

Hearken to the newest from Playing cards Wire’s Jess Root on his podcast, Rise Up, See Pink. Subscribe on Apple podcasts or Spotify.

Newest present:

Earlier exhibits:


Arizona Cardinals: CB Byron Murphy

AP Picture/Rick Scuteri

Murphy enters a essential season in 2022 within the last 12 months of his rookie contract. The crew speaks of him as a defensive star, however his play has been uneven at greatest for 3 seasons. He does his greatest work within the slot however struggled within the second half of the season. His protection numbers weren’t unhealthy in 2021. He allowed 64 receptions for 731 yards and 5 touchdowns in 98 targets and he had 4 interceptions, however of all of the discuss of him being their greatest cornerback, it was Robert Alford final season that held the cornerback room collectively. – Jess Root, Playing cards Wire

Atlanta Falcons: LB Deion Jones

Dale Zanine-USA TODAY Sports activities

Jones is the crew’s highest-paid participant however his play didn’t replicate that in 2021. The previous Professional Bowl inside linebacker is greatest suited to play in a 4-3 protection just like the one Atlanta ran beneath former head coach Dan Quinn. Since Dean Pees got here on because the defensive coordinator, Jones hasn’t regarded practically as comfy. Regardless of recording 137 mixed tackles final season, Jones was usually misplaced and struggled when dropping into protection. The previous LSU star was focused 92 instances, permitting 78 catches for 884 receiving yards and 4 touchdowns. Atlanta seems to be seeking to transfer on from Jones after signing free brokers Rashaan Evans and Nick Kwiatkoski, whereas drafting Troy Andersen within the second spherical. – Matt Urben, Falcons Wire

Baltimore Ravens: CB Kyle Fuller

Isaiah J. Downing-USA TODAY Sports activities

Fuller was introduced in by the Ravens on a one-year deal to be cornerback depth, however it’s unclear simply how impactful he’ll be. He had a tough go throughout his last 12 months with the Broncos, and hasn’t regarded just like the participant he was just some seasons in the past when he was at his greatest in Chicago with the Bears. Fuller is the No. 3 cornerback in Baltimore’s protection and shall be relied upon to probably play each inside and outdoors. Hopefully he’ll have the ability to take action at a excessive degree and bounce again from his 2021 season. – Kevin Oestreicher, Ravens Wire

Buffalo Payments: OL Spencer Brown

Wealthy Barnes-USA TODAY Sports activities

We will admit it, Brown’s beer chugging landing celebration was cool final season. However in 12 months 2, he has room to enhance. Brown ended up beginning 10 video games as a rookie and performed admirably in 2021. He recorded a strong 62.1 total grade for his efforts final 12 months from Professional Soccer Focus. Nonetheless, it’s clear to see the place enchancment is required. As a move protector, PFF solely graded Brown a brutal 49.1 total and he took eight penalties in his first 12 months. There’s loads of motive to be optimistic that such a younger participant can enhance, however Brown isn’t the stud some consider him to be already. – Nick Wojton, Payments Wire

Carolina Panthers: LB Shaq Thompson

Jim Dedmon-USA TODAY Sports activities

Thompson, under no circumstances, is a nasty participant. The truth is, he’s in all probability coming off probably the most impactful marketing campaign of his profession. It’s simply fairly tough to pinpoint an overrated participant on a crew that, properly, nobody actually bothers to fee a lot as of late. Though he’s a extremely revered chief amongst his friends, Thompson has but to persistently dwell as much as the first-round decide he was drafted with in addition to the $54 million contract he inked in 2019. And possibly that’s not his fault, seeing as if investing that a lot into that specific place isn’t precisely the soundest of enterprise choices. However for a man who was drafted to be a game-altering, ball-mongering presence on protection—he’s registered simply three interceptions, 4 pressured fumbles, zero fumble recoveries and 11.5 sacks over seven seasons. – Anthony Rizzuti, Panthers Wire

Chicago Bears: S Eddie Jackson

USA Immediately Sports activities

There was a time when Jackson was probably the greatest safeties within the NFL. His first two seasons had been promising, the place he totaled eight interceptions, three pressured fumbles and scored 5 defensive touchdowns from 2017-18. He was additionally a two-time Professional Bowler in 2018 and 2019. However he’s been unable to copy his manufacturing from his first two seasons, made much more maddening since signing a four-year, $58.4 million extension in 2019. Jackson, who carries the second-highest cap hit, hasn’t recorded an interception in two seasons, and he’s acquired loads of criticism for lacking tackles and his effort. Maybe the addition of second-round rookie Jaquan Brisker, who is anticipated to begin at sturdy security, will assist Jackson, who may have the chance to get again to his ballhawking methods. – Alyssa Barbieri, Bears Wire

Cincinnati Bengals: WR Tyler Boyd

Andy Lyons/Getty Pictures

This one in all probability received’t go over too properly with followers, however Boyd has been swept up within the hype of Ja’Marr Chase and Tee Higgins a bit. Little doubt the Bengals have a depraved three-man set at wideout and Boyd is an outstanding slot man. And sure, he needed to operate because the No. 1 receiver for 2 years throughout a slog of a rebuild whereas A.J. Inexperienced floundered. However he is likely to be off the sphere if the offense desires Chase within the slot or to solely run two wideouts. He’s nice, however he’s not in the identical bracket because the likes of Cooper Kupp and Hunter Renfrow. – Chris Roling, Bengals Wire

Cleveland Browns: DE Jadeveon Clowney

Jeffrey Becker-USA TODAY Sports activities

On the identical time that Clowney is overrated he was additionally a key participant the crew wanted to return this 12 months. The previous prime total decide and bodily marvel is basically good at setting the sting together with his size and power however he’s by no means been a pure move rusher. Taking part in reverse Myles Garrett helped Clowney compile 9 sacks in simply 14 video games final 12 months however he’s not often the disruptive drive many consider with the previous South Carolina star. Good, simply not nice. – Jared Okay. Mueller, Browns Wire

Dallas Cowboys: WR Michael Gallup

Tim Heitman-USA TODAY Sports activities

This can be a one-year dialog solely, however the expectations round what Gallup can contribute in 2022 appear ill-conceived and far-fetched. Gallup had a tough 2021, dropping a number of weeks early with a calf harm after which struggling an ACL tear in December. The membership initially spewed their spin management Gallup could possibly be prepared to begin the season. A giant-play menace, it’s onerous to fathom Gallup getting again to premier vogue in 2022 with out an offseason and coaching camp, no less than in time to have WR2 manufacturing numbers. – Okay.D. Drummond, Cowboys Wire

Denver Broncos: OLB Bradley Chubb

Robert Reiners/Getty Pictures

It’s doable to be overrated whereas nonetheless being an excellent participant. Chubb has the expertise – he totaled 12 sacks as a rookie in 2018 – however varied accidents have prevented him from dwelling as much as his excessive draft standing since then. The previous fifth total decide has missed 24 of the crew’s final 49 video games, and he’s solely totaled 8.5 sacks during the last three years (zero in seven video games final season). He’s a reputation participant – Chubb was voted to the Professional Bowl after totaling 7.5 sacks in 2020 – however accidents have prevented him from producing the sort of numbers followers would anticipate from the fifth-best participant in a draft class. If he can keep wholesome this 12 months, maybe Chubb will return to his rookie kind in 2022. – Jon Heath, Broncos Wire

Detroit Lions: RB D’Andre Swift

Joe Nicholson-USA TODAY Sports activities

Swift is a high quality working again who can positively make particular issues occur with the ball in his arms. He’s confirmed to be probably the greatest receiving threats within the league at his place. However Swift’s status as a runner significantly exceeds what he’s really executed, particularly between the tackles. Whereas he’s an amazing menace in area, Swift goes down on first contact too simply and lacks the decisive imaginative and prescient and highly effective model to thrive as an every-down again. He was the least-effective runner on the crew in 2021. – Jeff Risdon, Lions Wire

Inexperienced Bay Packers: S Darnell Savage

Kim Klement-USA TODAY Sports activities

This was a troublesome one. We really picked Savage because the crew’s breakout participant in 2022, so additionally having him because the “most overrated” is a little bit robust to sq.. However it’s really robust to know the place Savage’s profession is heading after a disappointing third season. He’s quick because the wind, and the Packers assume he is usually a versatile playmaker, however there’s been too many missed alternatives, too many missed tackles and too many massive performs allowed, particularly final season. If all the pieces comes collectively, Savage could possibly be a Professional Bowler. However there’s additionally an opportunity he’s only a actually quick defensive again with some warts that received’t go away. The Packers have and may win with Savage, however will he attain his potential as one of many recreation’s greatest safeties? Who is aware of. – Zach Kruse, Packers Wire

Houston Texans: LT Laremy Tunsil

AP Picture/Jason Behnken

The train borders on the satirical to call an overrated Texans participant contemplating they don’t have any face of the franchise. Nonetheless it must be Tunsil resulting from his standing as a two-time Professional Bowler, and his absence by way of the ultimate 12 video games in 2021. Houston additionally reworked Tunsil’s contract to maintain him with the franchise by way of 2023 with wage cap hits of $17.7 million and $35.2 million. Something in need of Professional Bowl seasons out of Tunsil at that value must be thought-about underachievement. – Mark Lane, Texans Wire

Indianapolis Colts: C Ryan Kelly

USA Immediately Sports activities

Simply because a participant is overrated doesn’t imply they’re unhealthy. Kelly is definitely not a nasty participant by any means. Nonetheless, Kelly was chosen to his third consecutive Professional Bowl in 2021 and if we’re being goal, it might not have been warranted. Kelly had an inconsistent season, permitting 29 complete pressures, good for the second-most amongst facilities. These 29 pressures and three sacks, in response to Professional Soccer Focus, had been probably the most of his profession. With Matt Ryan now beneath middle, Kelly is due for a bounce-back season. However his 2021 marketing campaign wasn’t as sturdy as his Professional Bowl nod could counsel. – Kevin Hickey, Colts Wire

Jacksonville Jaguars: TE Chris Manhertz

Nathan Ray Seebeck-USA TODAY Sports activities

The Jags signed Chris Manhertz final season in free company, and whereas he was identified extra for his blocking means, they had been in all probability hoping he confirmed promise as a receiver, too. There was a chance to turn into the man for the crew when James O’Shaughnessy went down with an ankle harm Week 2, however that by no means actually occurred. The truth is, it might be telling that the Jags acquired Dan Arnold, who established a very good reference to Lawrence, by way of a commerce early within the season. The crew additionally added one other tight finish this offseason in Evan Engram, which confirmed their dissatisfaction on the place and should additional bump Manhertz down the depth chart. – James Johnson, Jaguars Wire

Kansas Metropolis Chiefs: DE Frank Clark

AP Picture/Gregory Bull

Relating to wage, manufacturing and title recognition, I’m unsure there’s a extra overrated participant on the Chiefs’ roster than Frank Clark. When he got here to Kansas Metropolis in commerce from Seattle, Clark was a pressure-producing pass-rusher with a knack for holding up within the run recreation. The Chiefs made Clark the highest-paid defensive participant on the crew again in 2019 and he put collectively a very good inaugural marketing campaign with 13 sacks and 64 pressures (incl. playoffs). He’s since didn’t play with any kind of consistency at one of many positions that the crew is most determined for manufacturing. – Charles Goldman, Chiefs Wire

Las Vegas Raiders: DE Chandler Jones

AP Picture/John Locher

Enable me to be clear: Jones remains to be an excellent participant. Nonetheless, he may not be fairly nearly as good as individuals keep in mind. Through the 2021 season, he totaled 10.5 sacks. Nonetheless, 5 of these got here in Week 1 in opposition to the Tennessee Titans. Within the last 16 video games of the season, he managed simply 5.5 sacks and eight tackles for a loss. Taking part in alongside Maxx Crosby ought to assist as he’ll lastly be enjoying acrossed one other bonafide star on the line of defense. However the days of Jones being a constant move rusher recreation in and recreation out are in all probability over. He’s higher off in a “No. 2” position than being the alpha rusher on a very good crew. – Marcus Mosher, Raiders Wire

Los Angeles Chargers: WR Keenan Allen

Kelvin Kuo-USA TODAY Sports activities

Allen being on this class could also be a daring assertion to some and this isn’t to say he’s a nasty participant, however him nonetheless being labeled as a top-10 wideout is wealthy. Whereas he has been atop probably the most receptions within the NFL over the previous 5 seasons, Allen failed to steer the crew in receiving yards, yards per reception and touchdowns final 12 months, coming in second behind Mike Williams. Additional, Allen was the league-leader in drops in 2021 (9). – Gavino Borquez, Chargers Wire

Los Angeles Rams: S Taylor Rapp

AP Picture/Kelvin Kuo

The Rams don’t actually have a participant who’s really overrated. Nonetheless, regardless of being a starter final 12 months, Rapp will not be the Rams’ most suitable choice subsequent to Jordan Fuller. He’s not nice in protection and may wrestle with tackling at instances, too, notably in the case of taking angles on ball carriers. Nick Scott appears to be the higher participant at this level, displaying vary and ball abilities within the playoffs final season. Rapp is a good backup, however in the case of starting-caliber gamers, Rapp must play a little bit bit higher. – Cameron DaSilva, Rams Wire

Miami Dolphins: CB Byron Jones

Mark J. Rebilas-USA TODAY Sports activities

It’s a bit more durable to decide on an overrated Dolphin, contemplating how a lot expertise the roster has now. Nonetheless, it could in all probability be Jones. Miami made him the highest-paid cornerback within the league again in 2020, giving him a five-year contract price $82 million. This offseason, Jones agreed to a restructure, however he’s nonetheless set to have cap hits of $18.85 million and $18.78 million in 2023 and 2024, respectively. During the last two seasons, Jones hasn’t had the eye-popping stats that will be anticipated from a participant with that contract. He’s performed 30 video games in aqua and orange, recording 95 tackles, 10 passes defended and simply two interceptions. With Xavien Howard having probably the most interceptions since getting into the league in 2016, it’s straightforward to neglect about Jones on the opposite facet. – Mike Masala, Dolphins Wire

Minnesota Vikings: CB Andrew Sales space Jr.

USA Immediately Sports activities

Rookie second-round draft decide Andrew Sales space Jr. is likely to be the longer term in Minnesota, however that doesn’t imply he’ll be the current. Cam Dantzler isn’t the attractive decide to begin reverse of Patrick Peterson at cornerback, however he is likely to be probably the most dependable at this level. Sales space is coming off a sports activities hernia surgical procedure, which has saved him from totally collaborating within the spring practices. So he’ll be enjoying catch-up with the protection as a rookie, whereas additionally competing with the extra skilled participant in Dantzler. Sales space might find yourself being probably the most “overrated participant” on the Vikings resulting from him not getting on the sphere. – Jordy McElroy, Vikings Wire

New England Patriots: DT Lawrence Man

Winslow Townson-USA TODAY Sports activities

He appears to be fading on a run protection that struggled in an enormous method in 2021. Defensive deal with Christian Barmore is trending towards being a star, although he’s enjoying sparingly in working conditions. But when Man (and Davon Godchaux) proceed to play under their potential, the Patriots might speed up Barmore’s ascent out of necessity. Man was one of many Patriots’ most underrated contributors as current as 2020. However his high quality of play is slipping. – Henry McKenna, Patriots Wire

New Orleans Saints: LG Andrus Peat

Chuck Prepare dinner-USA TODAY Sports activities

Andrus Peat is a three-time Professional Bowler who has additionally been on the scene of the crime for a number of the worst moments in current reminiscence; he’s who Aaron Donald acquired previous to interrupt Drew Brees’ throwing hand again in 2019, and he’s who acquired pushed again into Jameis Winston to trigger an opening-drive interception at Washington final 12 months. Accidents have restricted him and saved him from ever enjoying a full schedule, and he appeared in a career-low six video games final season. However he’s loved the advantages of enjoying on an always-talented unit as a former first-round decide, and that title recognition has been sufficient to carry him to a number of Professional Bowls. Professional Soccer Focus has charged him with 20 or extra pressures yearly he’s performed however 2021, once they discovered he allowed 14 pressures throughout simply six video games. – John Sigler, Saints Wire

New York Giants: WR Kenny Golladay

AP Picture/Steve Luciano

Golladay is the simple reply right here for apparent causes. Some could argue he can’t be thought-about overrated after dropping the religion of many following a career-worst efficiency in 2021 however primarily based on his contract and projected position, he’s being positioned right here anyway. Golladay was supposed to return in and repair the crew’s points at extensive receivers however as a substitute, he solely added to them. He struggled with drops in his first season with the Giants and his catch share of 48.7 was a career-low. Beneath Brian Daboll and Mike Kafka, it stays to be seen what Golladay’s position is. The offensive is prone to be extra unfold out and quick, which doesn’t precisely match his receiving model. – Dan Benton, Giants Wire

New York Jets: LB C.J. Mosley

USA Immediately Sports activities

Mosley is on the intersection of being overrated and overpaid. His contract is what makes him overrated as a result of because the third-most costly linebacker within the NFL, he’s not dwelling as much as expectations. Sure, he had 168 tackles and two sacks final season, however he was horrible in protection and PFF gave him an total grade of simply 42.0. There’s nonetheless time for him to play the way in which the Jets are paying him to, however to this point, his tenure in New York has been disappointing. The Jets want extra from their prime linebacker in 2022. – Cameron DaSilva, Jets Wire

Philadelphia Eagles: RB Miles Sanders

AP Picture/John Munson

Sanders is explosive and has been a productive working again when wholesome, lacking 9 complete video games over the previous two seasons. Sanders averages nearly 5 yards a carry and is a house run hitter when utilized, however the Eagles offense additionally doesn’t miss a beat when he’s out of the lineup, and the North-South working model displayed by Boston Scott and Kenneth Gainwell is extra conducive to Philadelphia’s offensive strategy. – Glenn Erby, Eagles Wire

Pittsburgh Steelers: WR Chase Claypool

Charles LeClaire-USA TODAY Sports activities

That’s to not say Chase Claypool is a nasty participant as a result of he isn’t. However there’s no denying he has underperformed in his profession to this point. Claypool isn’t missing in confidence this offseason and says he’s a top-three receiver within the league. However at this level, he’s been all potential and much much less manufacturing. – Curt Popejoy, Steelers Wire

San Francisco 49ers: LB Dre Greenlaw

© Sergio Estrada-USA TODAY Sports activities

It’s onerous to search out an ‘overrated’ participant on the 49ers’ roster, however Greenlaw jumps out because the participant with the very best ceiling and lowest ground. Whereas he brings a ton of athleticism and suits the fashionable linebacker prototype, he’s had bouts with missed tackles and inconsistency in protection throughout his profession. Final season’s small pattern measurement confirmed some enhancements in these areas from Greenlaw, particularly in his return from a groin harm that restricted him to simply three common season video games. Nonetheless, there’s no assure that step ahead carries over into 2022, and a participant dubbed a part of the greatest linebacker duo within the NFL might really lose his spot as a three-down LB for San Francisco. – Kyle Madson, Niners Wire

Seattle Seahawks: HC Pete Carroll

Pete Carroll

Pete Carroll

Thomas Shea-USA TODAY Sports activities

It’s onerous to pinpoint any overrated gamers on this roster proper now, so I’ll decide Carroll. Whereas he has a well-earned status as a defensive genius, Carroll has been too gradual to embrace change on each side of the ball and it’s value his crew dearly. Defensively Carroll is lastly shifting away from cowl 3 however that change ought to have began 4 years in the past after Kris Richard was fired. Offensively his refusal to embrace a contemporary pass-first assault led by former QB Russell Wilson could have restricted the Seahawks’ near-dynasty to 1 ring greater than some other issue. – Tim Weaver, Seahawks Wire

Tampa Bay Buccaneers: Okay Ryan Succop

Kim Klement-USA TODAY Sports activities

Succop gave the impression to be the long-awaited resolution for the Bucs’ kicking woes with a robust 2020 marketing campaign as Tampa Bay marched all the way in which to the Tremendous Bowl, however there was noticeable regression final season. Succop’s subject objective conversion fee dropped from 90 to 83 p.c, and he missed 4 of his 11 makes an attempt from exterior of 40 yards. Succop will flip 36 in September, and it’s solely doable that the youthful and cheaper Jose Borregales beats him out in coaching camp. – Luke Easterling, Bucs Wire

Tennessee Titans: LB Zach Cunningham

Steve Roberts-USA TODAY Sports activities

After falling into the Titans’ lap by way of waivers, Cunningham shortly secured a beginning position and made a major influence within the last 5 video games of the season (together with playoffs). Nonetheless, nearly as good as Cunningham is as a tackler and in opposition to the run, he’s the precise reverse in the case of protection. Over 4 common season video games with Tennessee, Cunningham posted a 78.6 p.c completion fee in opposition to and allowed a passer score of 112.2. Continued struggles in that space might result in Cunningham seeing much less snaps in apparent passing conditions. – Mike Moraitis, Titans Wire

Washington Commanders: DE Chase Younger

Chase Young

Chase Younger

Raj Mehta-USA TODAY Sports activities

This isn’t honest to Younger, as a result of he didn’t place the large expectations on himself. Like Roullier, he additionally suffered a season-ending leg harm final season. Nonetheless, he falls on this listing as a result of within the 9 video games he did play in final season, he recorded simply 1.5 sacks. Sure, sacks aren’t the one metric used to find out how efficient a pass-rusher is, however a participant as gifted as Younger ought to register extra sacks. The excellent news is Younger’s rehab goes properly and he ought to return someday early within the season, if not earlier than. Don’t be stunned if Younger is a major contender for NFL comeback participant of the 12 months. – Bryan Manning, Commanders Wire